In crisis? Call 999 or Samaritans free on 116 123. Other ways to get help

Selective mutism: signs, causes and how to help

Selective mutism is an anxiety disorder where a person cannot speak in certain situations, such as at school, despite speaking freely elsewhere. Learn the signs and how families and schools can help.

Last reviewed · 3 min read

What is selective mutism?

Selective mutism is an anxiety disorder where a person is unable to speak in certain social situations, such as at school or with relatives they do not see often, but speaks freely in others, typically at home with close family.

It usually starts in early childhood, often becoming noticeable when a child starts nursery or school. It is important to understand that it is not a choice, defiance or shyness. The child wants to speak but freezes because of intense anxiety, much like stage fright.

Signs of selective mutism

  • speaking normally at home but consistently not speaking at school or in other settings
  • freezing, looking blank or avoiding eye contact when expected to talk
  • relying on gestures, nodding or pointing to communicate
  • seeming stiff, tense or awkward in social situations
  • the pattern lasting more than a month (not counting the first month at a new school)

Without support, selective mutism can continue into the teenage years and adulthood, and some adults experience it too.

What causes it?

Selective mutism is linked to an anxious temperament and a strong fear of being heard or watched speaking. It is more common in children with a family history of anxiety, in children learning a second language, and in some children with speech and language difficulties. It is not usually caused by trauma.

How selective mutism is treated

Treatment works best when it starts early and involves the family and school together:

  • Graded exposure, often called "sliding in": gradually introducing new people into situations where the child already feels comfortable talking.
  • Stimulus fading and shaping: building from non-verbal communication to sounds, single words, then sentences.
  • CBT for older children, teenagers and adults.
  • Support from a speech and language therapist or educational psychologist.

How parents and teachers can help

  • Remove the pressure to speak. Avoid pleading, bribing or praising speech in front of others.
  • Comment, do not question. Say "I wonder if that's a red car" instead of "What colour is the car?"
  • Allow other ways to communicate, such as pointing, writing or nodding, while working on speech gradually.
  • Wait patiently if the child might answer, then move on without fuss.
  • Do not label the child as "shy" or "the one who doesn't talk" in front of them.
  • Work together so home and school use the same approach.

Frequently asked questions

Is selective mutism a form of autism?

No. Selective mutism is an anxiety disorder, although some autistic children also experience it. A professional assessment can help identify any additional needs.

Will my child grow out of selective mutism?

Some children improve as they grow, but many need support. Early help makes a big difference and reduces the risk of it continuing into adulthood.

Is my child being stubborn?

No. Children with selective mutism are not refusing to speak. Their anxiety physically stops them. Pressure to speak usually makes the anxiety, and the silence, worse.

Sources

This page is general information, not medical advice. Speak to a GP or qualified professional about your own situation. Read our medical disclaimer.